A late notice can undermine a construction payment decision

A payment claim and the right to use adjudication are separate questions.

In Chase Oyster Bar Pty Ltd v Hamo Industries Pty Ltd [2010] NSWCA 190, a notice requirement affected the adjudicator’s legal power to decide a claim. The case shows why the steps used to pursue payment can matter as much as the amount claimed.

What happened

Chase engaged Hamo to carry out fitout work at an oyster bar in Chatswood. Hamo served a payment claim. Chase gave no payment schedule, a response stating what it proposed to pay, and did not pay. Hamo then sought adjudication under the NSW security of payment law. [114]-[119]

For that route, section 17(2) required notice of the intention to seek adjudication within 20 business days after payment fell due. It also required an opportunity to provide a payment schedule. The Court held that the notice requirement had not been met, although the adjudicator had treated it as satisfied. [117]-[121], [189]

What the Court decided

The NSW Court of Appeal held that timely notice was an essential condition of a valid application under this route. Without it, the adjudicator lacked power to determine the application. The adjudicator’s view that the requirement had been met did not bind the Court. [96]-[103]

The Supreme Court could set aside the determination for this jurisdictional error, an error concerning the limits of legal power. The Court of Appeal answered the referred questions; it left the consequential orders to the Equity Division. [108]-[109], [267]

What this does, and does not, mean

The failed adjudication route did not necessarily end the claim for payment. McDougall J explained that an action to recover the amount as a debt could remain available. Losing one procedure is different from losing the underlying claim. [216]-[217]

Nor does every legal mistake allow a court challenge. In Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd [2018] HCA 4, the High Court held that the NSW scheme excluded this form of review for a legal error in the recorded decision that was not jurisdictional. [2], [29]-[35]

Questions for your lawyer

  • Which notice and service requirements apply to this payment dispute, and when must each step occur?

  • Does the alleged error concern the adjudicator’s legal power?

  • If adjudication is unavailable, what other recovery route remains, and what would it cost?

This article explains a NSW decision under the law considered by the Court. It is general information, not a timetable for a current claim.

Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Before taking work away from a contractor

Next
Next

Can retention money depend on the whole project being finished?