Lost business opportunities: what was the chance worth?

Home > Case Law Library > Contract > Sellars v Adelaide Petroleum NL [1994] HCA 4

Published: 29 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)

A lost business opportunity may have value even if success was less likely than failure. But claiming the full hoped-for profit can overstate the loss.

In Sellars, the High Court explained the difference between proving that a valuable opportunity was lost and deciding what it was worth.

One deal displaced another

Adelaide Petroleum and its directors were negotiating with two companies about restructuring the business.

They stopped pursuing a proposed deal with Pagini and signed an agreement with Poseidon. The trial judge found that misleading statements about Poseidon’s intended involvement were a substantial factor in that choice.

After the Poseidon arrangement failed, a later deal with Pagini was reached. The claimants said its terms were less favourable. Adelaide and the other claimants sought compensation for the earlier opportunity they had lost.
Source: joint reasons, [2]-[6].

The deal did not have to be certain

The trial judge found that the earlier Pagini agreement would have been signed without the misleading statements. Completion remained uncertain: finance, approvals and other conditions still stood in the way.

He assessed the benefits that completion would have brought, then reduced that figure to 40% to reflect the risk that the deal would not proceed. Some items received further reductions.

The High Court dismissed the appeals against the damages award. The chance of completion had value even though completion was not more likely than not.
Source: joint reasons, [13], [38]-[42].

Proof of loss comes before its value

The joint reasons drew two distinct questions:

  • Was a valuable opportunity lost because of the misleading conduct? The claimants had to prove this on the balance of probabilities.

  • What was that opportunity worth? The court assessed the chances of obtaining the benefit, including the obstacles that might have prevented it.

The lost chance was the loss; the hoped-for profit was the starting point for valuing it.

This did not remove the need to prove causation or show that the opportunity had more than negligible value.
Source: joint reasons, [38]-[40].

Evidence must explain the chance

For someone considering a similar claim, the practical task is to identify the opportunity and the steps between it and a financial return.

Draft terms, correspondence, finance arrangements and required approvals may help show how far the deal had progressed and what could still have stopped it. This is a practical inference from the evidence examined in Sellars, rather than a checklist imposed by the Court.
Source: joint reasons, [8]-[13].

The limits matter

The case concerned commercial loss under the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth). It does not establish that every missed opportunity attracts compensation.

In Berry v CCL Secure Pty Ltd [2020] HCA 27, Bell, Keane and Nettle JJ restated the distinction between proving the loss of a valuable commercial opportunity and estimating its value.

Different considerations apply to claims about a lost chance of a better medical outcome, as the High Court explained in Tabet v Gett [2010] HCA 12.

Questions to ask your lawyer

  • What evidence shows that the other party’s conduct caused us to lose a valuable opportunity?

  • Which risks should reduce the amount we claim?

By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
Nicky Wang, Principal Solicitor

Nicky Wang is Principal Solicitor of Clean Law, a Sydney-based legal practice focused on civil litigation cost behaviour, settlement structure, litigation funding control, and client-side cost visibility. Her work examines how legal costs, incentives, information timing and role design affect the real financial outcome of civil disputes.

Previous
Previous

Good faith negotiations: must you reach a deal?

Next
Next

When poor advice is not a breach of loyalty