Home > Case Law Library > Contract > United Group Rail Services Limited v Rail Corporation New South Wales [2009] NSWCA 177 (NSW Court of Appeal | 3 July 2009)Published: 30 January 2025 | Reviewed: 8 October 2026
(3-minute read)
A contract may require you to try to resolve a dispute before arbitration. Does that mean you must accept a deal?
A duty to negotiate in good faith can bind how you negotiate without requiring you to reach agreement. This case explains that distinction in a contract with an express dispute resolution clause. [69]-[77]
What the contract required
United had agreed to design and build new trains for Railcorp. Their contracts required senior representatives to meet and negotiate genuinely and in good faith. The process also provided for mediation and arbitration. [1], [15]
United argued that the negotiation clause was too uncertain to enforce. Both parties accepted that the mediation clause was unenforceable because the named dispute centre did not exist. United argued that the arbitration clause could not survive those defects. [20]-[22]
What the Court decided
The Court upheld the negotiation clause. Its words had a workable meaning in the context of an existing contract and disputes about the rights and duties it created. Allsop P gave the reasons. Ipp JA and Macfarlan JA agreed. [69]-[81], [100]-[101]
The arbitration clause also remained enforceable despite the defective mediation provision. The Court dismissed United’s appeal with costs. [87]-[99]
You can protect your own interests
The clause required an honest and genuine attempt to resolve the dispute, based on the parties’ honestly held views of their contractual rights and duties. It did not require either party to advance the other’s interests. [70]-[77]
Allsop P gave an example of conduct outside that standard: pretending to negotiate while planning to force a claim known to be good into an arbitration the other party could not afford. This was an illustration, not a finding about either party. [73]
An honest disagreement about the facts or the contract could remain. The clause did not turn that disagreement into an obligation to accept the other side’s position. [70], [73], [76]
The wording and context matter
This decision concerned an express promise to negotiate about disputes under existing contracts. It did not decide that every negotiation carries the same duty, or that every good faith clause is enforceable. Its meaning depends on the words and context. [61], [66], [69]-[70]
The appeal addressed whether the clauses could be enforced. It did not decide whether either party had breached the negotiation duty. [20]-[27]
Questions to ask your lawyer
What steps does our dispute clause require, and by when?
What would genuine participation require from us?
If talks fail, or one step cannot work, what happens next?
By Nicky Wang
Principal Solicitor
